Sunday, May 8, 2016

Case Digest: Lucas vs. Tuaño

PETER PAUL PATRICK LUCAS, et al. vs. DR. PROSPERO MA. C. TUAÑO
G.R. NO. 178763 21 April 2009
Chico-Nazario, J.


DOCTRINES:

In a medical negligence suit, the patient or his heirs, in order to prevail, is required to prove by preponderance of evidence that the physician failed to exercise that degree of skill, care, and learning possessed by other persons in the same profession; and that as a proximate result of such failure, the patient or his heirs suffered damages.

There is breach of duty of care, skill and diligence, or the improper performance of such duty, by the attending physician when the patient is injured in body or in health constitutes the actionable malpractice.

FACTS:

Herein petitioner, Peter Lucas, first consulted respondent, Dr. Tuaño, on a complaint of soreness and redness on his right eye. The respondent, after a series of examinations, found that the former was suffering from conjunctivitis or “sore eyes” and prescribed the use of the Spersacet-C.  However, after the petitioner’s condition seemed to have worsened, he sought for the respondent’s second finding wherein the latter said that his condition had progressed to Epidemic Kerato Conjunctivitis (EKC), a viral infection.  The respondent then prescribed the use of Maxitrol, a steroid-based eye drop. The petitioner’s condition worsened overtime, yet he obediently complied with all the prescriptions and orders of the respondent.

Four months later and after the petitioner suffered from significant swelling of his right eyeball, headaches, nausea and blindness on this right eye, he sought for the opinion of another doctor, Dr. Aquino. Dr. Aquino found that the petitioner had been suffering from glaucoma and needed to undergo laser surgery, lest he might suffer from total blindness.

After reading the literature on the use of the medicine Maxitrol, Fatima, one of the petitioners herein and Peter Lucas’ wife, read that one of the adverse effects of prolonged use of steroid-based eye drops could possibly be glaucoma.  Peter, Fatima, and their two children instituted a civil case for damages against herein respondent for medical malpractice.


ISSUE:

Whether or not the petitioners amply proved that Dr. Tuaño failed to exercise diligence in the performance of his duty as petitioner Peter Lucas’ physician.

RULING:

No. Absent a definitive standard of care or diligence required of Dr. Tuaño under the circumstances, the Court has no yardstick upon which to evaluate the attendant facts of the case at hand to be able to state with confidence that the acts complained of, indeed, constituted negligence and, thus, should be the subject of pecuniary reparation.

In medical negligence cases, also called medical malpractice suits, there exist a physician-patient relationship between the doctor and the victim.  But just like any other proceeding for damages, four essential (4) elements i.e., (1) duty; (2) breach; (3) injury; and (4) proximate causation, must be established by the plaintiff/s.  All the four (4) elements must co-exist in order to find the physician negligent and, thus, liable for damages.

As the physician has the duty to use at least the same level of care as that of any other reasonably competent physician would use in the treatment of his patient, said standard level of care, skill and diligence must likewise be proven by expert medical testimony, because the standard of care in a medical malpractice case is a matter peculiarly within the knowledge of experts in the field. The same is outside the ken of the average layperson.


There is breach of duty of care, skill and diligence, or the improper performance of such duty, by the attending physician when the patient is injured in body or in health [and this] constitutes the actionable malpractice. Hence, proof of breach of duty on the part of the attending physician is insufficient. Rather, the negligence of the physician must be the proximate cause of the injury.

1 comment:

  1. I am very much happy to share to every viewers that is reading this,I want to inform the whole public of how I got help for my herpes, I wanted this since 6 months ago, I have also taken treatment from some doctor,few weeks back I came on the net to see if I will be able to get any information as to cure my herpes, on my search I saw various testimony of people who was helped by a great man called Dr Akhigbe and without any hesitation, I contacted him, I wrote to him and and he guided me, I asked him for solutions and he started the remedies for me and indeed 3 weeks after I started using the medicine, I was completely happy as it worked for me.I went to the hospital for check up and indeed I was declared negative from my disease, and I also waited again for two weeks and went back to another hospital for check up to be fully sure and to my great surprise I was still declared negative, and I decided to share this great opportunity to those people out there fighting this sickness, You can contact him now for your medicine to cure your diseases, contact his Email;  drrealakhigbe@gmail.com     or     Whatsapp     +2349010754824    website. http://drrealakhigbe.weebly.comDr  Akhigbe also cure diseases like..
    HIV,  Herpes , Cancer,  Chronic Disease,  Asthma ,  Parkinson's disease,  External infection,  Als, progeria, common cold,  multiple sclerosis disease,   Nausea, Vomiting or Diarrhea, Heart Disease, meningitis, Esquizofrenia, Toxoplasmosis, Pulmonary Fibrosis,Diabetes,  Kidney Disease,  Lupus,  Epilepsy,   Stroke,Eczema, Erysipelas, Tetanus,  Eating Disorder,  Back Pain. Osteoporosis etccontact him for your solution.

    ReplyDelete